On women in computer science

I could talk about this subject all day, really, but don’t worry; I won’t.
“Of Geeks and Girls” is an interesting article. Its main argument — and this is part of scientific research, not just soapboxing — is that it’s not necessarily the low proportions of fellow women that keep girls out of computer science. It’s the environment, the image, and the general “girls not welcome here” feeling that one gets when sitting in a place surrounded by Star Wars posters, Red Bull cans and that lingering odour of nerdy undergraduates who haven’t discovered showers yet.
I find the argument around this fascinating for two reasons. Firstly, because it’s being hotly contested by men: “We don’t keep women out! We’re inclusive and nice!” Are you really? (And here’s where, as with any post on this topic, the generalisations start to appear. Sorry.) Just because you painted the walls of your computer lab pink doesn’t mean you’re inclusive. Do you value a geeky girl who may appreciate different things (books, Blythes, craft, cosplay, independent cinema, Nintendo, anime, WoW, name your thing), or is it only science fiction, Linux kernel hacking and Android development that count? Do you make the same assumptions about a female you meet in a computer lab as you do a male? Or do you assume that if a girl puts her hand up for a TA that she’s stuck, and if a guy does, he’s pointing out an error in the assignment?
Anyway, as a female person who’s been in and around academic computer science for the last decade or so, I find it infinitely amusing that people care more about their own opinions than mine; people have corrected me on my own experiences, saying their “friends” (who they greatly “respect”, of course!) found it different, and so I must be mistaken..!
The second reason is because it’s something far more actionable than many of the other societal factors often pointed to as the reason for female underrepresentation. Want to start appealing to women? Stop appealing to geeks and start just appealing to everyone. (This is why many of the ‘wider audience’ videogames are taking off — they’re totally agnostic. Doesn’t everyone want to be a rock star, to get fit, or to become Prince of the Cosmos?)
Of course, the flipside is that by de-geekifying computer science, you actually lose geek cred and possibly antagonise the female geeks (as we all identify strongly with the geek stereotype, and we certainly don’t want to project the image that no girls like Star Wars action figures, etc). Tricky, no? How can we get the best of both worlds?


Recent Comments